Reporting, Annual Returns, and Impact

TL;DR Every registered charity in England and Wales must file an annual return and accounts with the Charity Commission. What is required depends on the charity's income, with thresholds determining whether you need a full audit, an independent examination, or simpler accounts. Beyond compliance, there is a growing expectation — from funders, the public, and the Charity Commission itself — that charities report meaningfully on their impact. Most charities meet the minimum reporting requirements; far fewer do a good job of explaining what difference they actually make.

Why this matters

Reporting is the primary mechanism through which charities account to the public for how they use charitable funds. The annual return feeds the Charity Commission's register, which is the main source of publicly available information about charities. Accounts and the trustees' annual report together tell the story of what the charity did, how it spent its money, and what it achieved.

Poor reporting erodes trust. When charities file late, submit incomplete returns, or produce accounts that obscure rather than illuminate, it undermines confidence in the sector as a whole. The Charity Commission's 2024 analysis of reporting standards found that while compliance rates have improved, the quality and usefulness of the information charities provide remains highly variable — particularly among smaller organisations.

The 5 things to know

1. Every registered charity must file an annual return

All registered charities with an income over £10,000 must complete the Charity Commission's annual return within 10 months of the end of their financial year. Charities with income under £10,000 must still update their details but complete a shorter return.

The annual return asks for basic information: the charity's income and expenditure, the number of staff and volunteers, whether the charity works with vulnerable groups, and details of any serious incidents. It also asks about governance — who the trustees are, whether they have conflicts of interest policies, and whether the charity has had its accounts independently examined or audited.

Since 2023, the annual return has included additional questions on safeguarding, equity, and diversity. The Charity Commission uses the data to monitor the sector, identify risks, and target its regulatory activity.

2. Accounts and the trustees' annual report are separate requirements

Alongside the annual return, charities must prepare annual accounts and a trustees' annual report (TAR). The format depends on the charity's income and legal structure:

Income under £250,000: Receipts and payments accounts (the simplest format) are acceptable unless the charity is a charitable company, in which case accruals accounts are required.
Income between £250,000 and £1 million: Accruals accounts prepared in accordance with the Charities SORP (Statement of Recommended Practice) are required, plus an independent examination.
Income over £1 million: Full accruals accounts under the SORP, plus a statutory audit by a registered auditor.
Charitable companies: Must also file accounts with Companies House, regardless of income.

The trustees' annual report must accompany the accounts and cover the charity's objectives and activities, achievements and performance, financial review, and plans for the future. For larger charities, the SORP requires the TAR to include a strategic report covering principal risks and uncertainties.

3. Audit vs independent examination depends on income thresholds

The distinction between audit and independent examination is important. An audit is a formal process carried out by a registered auditor, providing a high level of assurance that the accounts give a true and fair view. An independent examination is a lighter-touch review carried out by someone with relevant expertise (an accountant, for example) but without the full rigour of an audit.

The current thresholds are:

Under £25,000 income: No external scrutiny required (though it is recommended).
£25,000 to £1 million income: Independent examination required.
Over £1 million income: Statutory audit required.
Over £3.26 million gross assets and income over £250,000: Audit also required regardless of the charity's overall income level.

These thresholds apply to charities that are not companies. Charitable companies follow Companies Act thresholds, which are broadly similar but not identical.

4. Impact reporting is increasingly expected but not legally required

There is a significant gap between compliance reporting — filing your annual return and accounts on time — and meaningful impact reporting. The annual return and accounts tell you what a charity spent its money on; they do not necessarily tell you what difference it made.

Impact reporting — measuring and communicating outcomes, not just outputs — has become a major theme in the sector. Funders increasingly ask for evidence of impact as a condition of grants. The public expects to know not just that a charity spent £500,000 on youth services, but what those services achieved for young people.

Frameworks like the Theory of Change, the Outcomes Star, and Social Return on Investment (SROI) have become more widely used. The Charity Commission's SORP encourages charities to report on outcomes in their trustees' annual report, but the quality of this reporting varies enormously.

5. Late or poor reporting has real consequences

Filing late or not at all is one of the most common compliance failures in the charity sector. The Charity Commission publishes a list of charities that are overdue with their annual returns, and persistent non-filing can trigger a compliance case and, ultimately, removal from the register.

Beyond regulatory action, poor reporting has practical consequences. Funders and institutional donors routinely check the Charity Commission register before making grants — a charity with overdue accounts or a patchy reporting history will struggle to secure funding. Poor reporting also makes it harder for the public to hold charities accountable, which damages trust in the sector as a whole.

The Charity Commission's 2024 analysis found that around 10% of registered charities were overdue with their annual return at any given time, and that the quality of trustees' annual reports — particularly the sections on achievements and performance — was inconsistent across the sector.

Common misunderstandings

"We're a small charity, so we don't really need to worry about reporting." All registered charities with income over £10,000 must file an annual return. Even charities below that threshold must keep their register entry up to date. Being small does not exempt you from accountability.

"Our accountant does our accounts, so reporting is sorted." Preparing accounts is only part of the requirement. The trustees' annual report is the board's responsibility, and it must describe the charity's activities, achievements, and plans — not just its finances. Many charities produce accounts that are technically compliant but accompanied by a report that says almost nothing useful.

"Impact measurement is just a funder requirement." Impact reporting serves the charity itself. If you do not understand what difference your work makes, you cannot improve it. Funders may have driven the trend, but the real beneficiaries of good impact reporting are the people the charity serves.

"Filing accounts with Companies House means we've met our Charity Commission obligations too." No. Charitable companies must file with both Companies House and the Charity Commission. They are separate requirements and have different deadlines.

How it works in practice

In a well-run charity, reporting is not an annual panic but an ongoing process. Financial data is kept up to date throughout the year, outcomes are tracked as programmes are delivered, and the trustees' annual report is drafted with the same care as a funder report.

The finance team or treasurer prepares the accounts, working with an external accountant or auditor as required. The CEO and senior team draft the narrative sections of the trustees' annual report, covering activities, achievements, and plans. The board reviews and approves both documents before they are filed.

Filing is done through the Charity Commission's online portal, typically within a few months of the financial year-end — well ahead of the 10-month deadline. The charity also publishes its accounts and report on its own website, making them easily accessible to anyone who wants to read them.

For impact reporting, the charity has a clear framework — a Theory of Change or logic model — that links its activities to the outcomes it aims to achieve. It collects data on those outcomes systematically and reports on them honestly, including where results have fallen short. The best impact reports are candid about what worked and what did not.

What people disagree about

Whether the current emphasis on impact measurement helps or hinders charities is genuinely contested. Supporters argue that measuring outcomes is essential for accountability and improvement. Critics argue that the burden of measurement falls disproportionately on smaller organisations, that not all outcomes can be meaningfully quantified, and that the demand for impact evidence can distort priorities towards easily measurable activities. See Impact Measurement Burden for a fuller discussion.

There is also ongoing debate about whether the Charity Commission's reporting requirements are proportionate. Some argue that the annual return is too blunt an instrument and fails to capture what matters about a charity's work. Others believe the Commission should demand more detailed reporting, particularly on governance, safeguarding, and diversity.

FAQs

What happens if a charity files its annual return late?

The Charity Commission will flag the charity as overdue on the public register, which is visible to anyone searching for the charity. Persistent late filing can trigger a regulatory compliance case, and charities that fail to file for extended periods risk being removed from the register entirely.

Does a charity need an audit if it is just over the £1 million threshold?

Yes. If a charity's gross income exceeds £1 million in a financial year, a statutory audit is required for that year's accounts. There is no grace period or rounding — the threshold is the threshold. Charitable companies may have slightly different thresholds under the Companies Act.

Can a charity publish its impact report instead of a trustees' annual report?

No — the trustees' annual report is a legal requirement and must cover specific content set out in the Charities SORP. However, many charities produce a separate impact report or integrated annual review that combines the statutory content with richer storytelling and impact data. The statutory TAR must still be filed with the Charity Commission.

Who is responsible for ensuring the charity's accounts are accurate?

The trustees, collectively. Even though accounts are usually prepared by staff or external accountants and scrutinised by an independent examiner or auditor, the trustees must approve them and are responsible for their accuracy. Signing off accounts without reading or understanding them is a governance failure.

Can we store cookies?